The Best Vegan Heavy Cream Substitute

If you miss the luxurious creaminess that traditional heavy cream brings to recipes, you aren’t alone. Many now look for dairy-free options, whether for a plant-based diet, lactose intolerance, or lighter eating. Vegan substitutes for heavy cream are more versatile and varied than ever, with choices spanning from nuts to coconut, plant-based yogurts, and clever blends. This guide dives into the best vegan heavy cream alternatives, when to use each, their textures and flavors, and how you can make them at home with easy instructions and tips to match any dish.

Why Find a Vegan Alternative to Heavy Cream?

The Best Vegan Heavy Cream Substitute Vertical Photo

Traditional heavy cream is admired for its rich texture and impressive versatility. It’s a foundation for whipped cream, soups, silky sauces, baked goods, salad dressings, and creamy desserts like mousse or custard. However, if you’re avoiding dairy, you need a substitute that mimics both consistency and taste, with the flexibility to perform in savory and sweet dishes alike.

What Makes a Great Vegan Heavy Cream Substitute?

A good substitute should:
– Blend smoothly
– Thicken or whip, depending on the recipe
– Provide mouthfeel without overpowering flavors
– Work well when heated or chilled

Different substitutes shine in different tasks. Choosing the right one depends on the recipe’s needs and your personal taste.

Common Uses for Heavy Cream

Before picking a vegan swap, identify your use. Here’s how heavy cream might appear in your cooking:

Whipped Topping: For pies, hot cocoa, or berries
Creamy Sauces: Like Alfredo or mushroom sauce
Soups: Adding body to blended soups
Baked Goods: Scones, biscuits, and cakes
Custards and Puddings: To add richness
Coffee and Beverages: As a decadent creamer
Savory Dishes: Mashed potatoes, risotto, and salad dressings

Each vegan alternative has strengths and limits in these areas.

The 8 Best Vegan Heavy Cream Substitutes

Below are the most reliable options, with preparation tips and best-use scenarios for each.

1. Cashew Cream

Cashew cream is remarkably close to dairy cream in thickness and smoothness. The subtle sweetness and nutty undertone pair well with both savory pastas and decadent desserts.

To Make:
– Soak 1 cup raw cashews in water for 2-4 hours (hot water speeds up the process).
– Drain and rinse the nuts, then blend with 1/2 to 1 cup water.
– For a thicker cream, use less water; add more for a pourable texture.

Best for: Dairy-free Alfredo, vegan cheesecake, creamy dressings, or stirred into soups.

Good to know: Won’t whip into peaks. Avoid for topping pies or cakes.

2. Coconut Cream or Full-Fat Coconut Milk

Coconut cream is extracted from the thick part of refrigerated canned coconut milk. It mimics dairy cream’s richness and whips beautifully.

To Use:
– Chill a can of full-fat coconut milk overnight.
– Scoop the solidified cream from the top; reserve liquid for other recipes.

Application	Suitability
Whipped topping	Excellent
Savory dishes	Good (imparts coconut flavor)
Baking	Great
Coffee/tea	Good for coconut fans

Best for: Whipped desserts, rich frostings, puddings, and Thai-inspired soups.

Tip: Coconut flavor can be strong—test it in your recipe first.

3. Dairy-Free Yogurt

Dairy-free yogurts, notably coconut, almond, and cashew-based ones, deliver creaminess and some of the signature tang of heavy cream.

How to Use:
– Substitute in a 1-to-1 ratio for most recipes.
– Look for unsweetened, unflavored yogurt to avoid adjusting sweetener levels in savory dishes.

Best for: Sauces, dressings, soups, or baked goods needing moisture and richness.

Bonus: Yogurt won’t whip, but provides a silky base for cold dishes.

4. Vegan Cream Cheese

Plant-based cream cheese gives recipes a dense, creamy consistency—ideal for both savory sauces and some desserts.

How to Use:
– Add 3/4 cup vegan cream cheese for every 1 cup heavy cream required.
– Soften it with a splash of plant milk for easier blending.

Best for: Creamy dips, frostings, soups, and pasta fillings.

Try it: Blended with herbs for a quick, dairy-free dip.

5. Sweetened Condensed Oat Milk

A newer arrival, sweetened condensed oat milk offers natural sweetness, a caramel-like note, and a thick consistency.

How to Use:
– Use 3/4 cup sweetened condensed oat milk for each cup of heavy cream.
– Works best when sweetness complements the recipe.

Best for: Vegan coffee creamer, ice cream, or rich caramel sauces.

6. Plain Soy Milk

Soy milk is protein-rich with a mild, neutral flavor. It blends well in baking or savory dishes, and when paired with other fats, performs even better as a cream replacement.

How to Use:
– Use a 1-to-1 ratio in baking or custards.
– Combine with melted vegan butter for sauces (see next).

Best for: Cupcakes, muffins, bread recipes, puddings, and custards.

7. Dairy-Free Butter & Plant Milk Blend

Blending any plant milk with vegan butter produces a cream alternative with a higher fat content, echoing dairy cream’s richness.

To Make:
– Blend 1 tablespoon melted vegan butter into 1/2 cup plant milk.
– Use as-is for creamy sauces, soups, or to enrich mashed potatoes.

Plant Milk	Flavor Profile
Almond Milk	Mild, slightly nutty
Oat Milk	Creamy, very neutral
Soy Milk	Mild and slightly beany

Tip: Adjust milk type for desired taste.

8. Silken Tofu & Plant Milk

Silken tofu whizzes up with plant milk into a thick, protein-packed cream that’s smooth, neutral, and customizable.

To Make:
– Blend 8 ounces silken tofu with 1/4 cup unsweetened plant milk.

Best for: Vegan cheesecakes, soups that need body, or creamy smoothie bowls.

Table: Quick Vegan Cream Substitute Cheat Sheet

Substitute	Whips?	Best Use	Notes
Cashew Cream	No	Sauces, desserts, bakes	Mild, slightly nutty
Coconut Cream	Yes	Whipped topping, baking	Distinct coconut flavor
Dairy-Free Yogurt	No	Soups, sauces, bakes	Tangy, moistens bakes
Vegan Cream Cheese	No	Dips, pasta, some bakes	Dense texture
Condensed Oat Milk	No	Sweet sauces, coffee, ice cream	Naturally sweet
Plain Soy Milk	No	Baking, custards, coffee	Best when paired w/ fat
Plant Milk & Vegan Butter	No	Soups, sauces, creamy bakes	Adjustable consistency
Silken Tofu & Plant Milk	No	Cheesecakes, mousse, soup	High protein

Tips for Success When Using Vegan Cream Substitutes

Always taste your substitute before adding. Adjust salt, sugar, or acidity as needed.
For whipping, the only reliable option is chilled coconut cream.
Use unsweetened versions for savory recipes.
Store homemade vegan creams in airtight containers for up to 3 days in the fridge.

Swapping Vegan Heavy Cream Substitutes in Real Recipes

Let’s see how these alternatives work in concrete examples:

Pasta Alfredo: Soaked cashews blended to a smooth paste mimic the original sauce’s silkiness.
Strawberry Shortcake: Chill coconut cream, then whip with a bit of powdered sugar for a classic topping.
Potato Soup: Silken tofu, puréed with soy milk, produces a creamy, thick soup foundation.
Coffee Creamer: Sweetened condensed oat milk stirs in for a rich, non-dairy finish.

Customizing Flavor and Texture

Don’t be afraid to tweak the basic recipes. Add lemon juice for tang, more water to thin, or a pinch of salt to balance sweetness. The flexibility of plant-based ingredients is one of their best features.

Conclusion: Finding Your Perfect Vegan Cream

With so many options at hand, there’s a perfect dairy-free cream substitute for any recipe. Experiment until you find your favorite. Keeping a stash of raw cashews and a can of coconut milk in your pantry guarantees you’ll always have a vegan heavy cream option on hand.

Whether you’re whipping, blending, or stirring, plant-based cream is more accessible and delicious than ever. Enjoy the creamy results—no dairy required.

The Best Vegan Heavy Cream Substitute
Jump to Recipe