Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Jump to Recipe

Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Nothing satisfies quite like the smoky heat of buffalo sauce, creamy cheese, and crisp golden bread fused into a hot, melty sandwich. Buffalo chicken grilled cheese sandwiches take comfort food and dial it up with bold flavors, creamy tang, and a substantial bite. This complete guide walks you through everything you need to create the ultimate buffalo chicken grilled cheese at home, from choosing your ingredients to assembling the perfect sandwich.

Why Make Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese?

This sandwich is more than just a twist on classic grilled cheese. It’s a combination of textures and flavors that play off each other beautifully—spicy chicken, oozy cheese, crusty bread, and cool creamy accents. Whether you’re feeding a crowd on game day or hunting for a filling lunch, this grilled cheese brings plenty of flavor without complicated steps or expensive ingredients.

Key benefits:
– Quick to prepare and great for using up leftover chicken.
– Easy to customize based on spice tolerance or cheese preference.
– Reheats well if you want to prep the filling and assemble sandwiches later.

Essential Ingredients

Let’s break down what you’ll need for a crave-worthy sandwich. Each ingredient plays a role in creating the right texture and taste.

Chicken
Use shredded cooked chicken breast or thigh. Rotisserie chicken works perfectly for convenience and added juiciness.

Buffalo Sauce
Traditional buffalo wing sauce—such as Frank’s RedHot or your favorite brand—provides heat, tang, and a touch of butteriness.

Mayonnaise
Spread on the bread, it encourages even toasting and helps the bread crisp up without burning. Use classic or vegan mayo as needed.

Sour Cream
Incorporate a scoop with the chicken and buffalo sauce. It mellows the heat and adds rich tang.

Cheese
Choose at least one creamy, meltable cheese and one with more bite:
– Monterey Jack: Excellent melt and mild balance.
– Cheddar or Colby Jack: A sharper, deeper base.
– Blue cheese: Optional, for that signature buffalo “bite.”
– Pepper Jack: Brings a hint of extra spice.

Bread
Pick a hearty, thick-sliced bread that resists sogginess and provides sturdy structure. Good options include:
– Sourdough
– Brioche
– Texas toast
– Potato bread

Seasonings and Fillings
– Garlic powder and dried parsley for depth
– Sliced green onions for a fresh finish
– Chopped celery or jalapeños for added crunch

Ingredient Table

How to Make Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese

Building this sandwich is straightforward but benefits from a few tried-and-true techniques. The key is layering your flavors and textures for maximum payoff in every bite.

1. Prepare the Chicken Mixture

Combine the cooked chicken, buffalo wing sauce, and sour cream in a bowl. Stir in garlic powder, parsley, and blue cheese if using. You want the filling thick and creamy but not drippy; add more sour cream for a milder experience or extra sauce if you love a fiery bite.

Tip: Shred the chicken finely so it melts into the cheese and holds together when you bite into the sandwich.

2. Prep the Bread

Lay out your bread slices. Spread mayonnaise on one side of each slice—this will be the outer sides that hit the pan. Mayo instead of butter gives a rich flavor and helps the exterior toast perfectly crisp and golden without burning as quickly as butter might.

3. Build the Sandwich

Place one bread slice, mayo-side down, on a clean board. Layer on half the Monterey Jack, then spoon the buffalo chicken mixture evenly over the cheese. Top with the remaining cheese, then finish with the second slice of bread, mayo-side up.

Layering order:
– Bread
– Cheese
– Buffalo chicken mixture
– More cheese (for optimal melt and “glue”)
– Bread

4. Toast & Melt

Heat a heavy skillet (cast iron works best) over medium-low. Lower the sandwich into the skillet and cover loosely with a lid. This gentle heat ensures the cheese melts throughout while the bread hits perfect golden brown. After 3–4 minutes, use a spatula to peek underneath. When golden, carefully flip and cook the other side, pressing gently. Both sides should be crisp and the cheese fully melted.

Examples:
For extra crunch, swap in fried chicken tenders or cutlets instead of shredded chicken. For a smoky edge, add a sprinkle of smoked paprika to the chicken mix.

5. Finishing Touches

Remove from the skillet and let it rest for a minute before slicing. A sharp serrated knife makes it easy to cut through the crispy bread without crushing the filling. Arrange with sides and dipping sauces.

Serving Ideas

Buffalo chicken grilled cheese sandwiches are a meal on their own but pair well with cooling, crunchy extras and classic dips.

Pairings:
– Celery and carrot sticks echo the wing-house vibe and cool the spice.
– Ranch or blue cheese dressing works as a dip.
– Potato chips, fries, or onion rings add a salty crunch.
– A crisp green salad with ranch vinaigrette balances richness.

Tips for Perfect Results

Getting the sandwich just right isn’t hard, but a few tweaks help guarantee success:

• Use medium-low heat. This way, the bread doesn’t burn before the cheese melts.
• Do not overload the sandwich. Too much filling will spill out and may make the bread soggy.
• Adjust buffalo sauce to personal taste. For kids or spice-sensitive eaters, go with mild sauce and increase sour cream.
• Add-ins like sliced jalapeños or chopped celery introduce more flavor and texture.
• Press sandwiches gently with a spatula while cooking—this encourages even browning and cheesy melt.

Customization & Variations

Experiment to match your preferences or dietary needs—this sandwich is endlessly adaptable:

Cheese swaps: Gouda, mozzarella, havarti, or American cheese
Bread: Gluten-free sandwich bread, multigrain, or rye
Spiced buttermilk chicken: Use leftover buttermilk fried chicken strips for a crunchier bite
Vegetarian twist: Substitute cooked chickpeas tossed in buffalo sauce
Heat level: Stir in a dash of cayenne, add pickled jalapeños, or use hotter buffalo sauces

Make-Ahead and Storage

If you’re planning on feeding a group, or want a quick lunch later in the week, prepare the spicy chicken mixture ahead and refrigerate in an airtight container for up to 4 days. Do not assemble or cook the sandwiches until just before serving; cooked grilled cheese can get soggy as it cools.

Reheating: If you need to reheat leftovers, place the sandwich in a dry skillet over low heat and cover. Warm gently on each side until hot and crisped.

Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Q&A

Can I substitute dairy-free cheese or yogurt?
Absolutely. Use your favorite dairy-free cheese slices or shreds and swap sour cream for plant-based yogurt.

What if I don’t like blue cheese?
Leave it out entirely or use ranch dressing mixed into the filling for tang.

Can I bake multiple sandwiches at once?
Yes. Arrange assembled sandwiches on a sheet pan, brush with mayo, and bake at 425°F (220°C) for 7–10 minutes per side, flipping halfway.

How spicy is it?
The heat level depends on your choice and amount of buffalo sauce. Adding extra sour cream buffers spice, while omitting it gives a sharper bite.

Buffalo chicken grilled cheese sandwiches turn everyday ingredients into a layered, flavorful meal. Combining spicy shredded chicken, gooey cheese, and crispy bread hits all the comforting notes—warm, hearty, satisfying, and just the right amount of messy. Add your personal spin with unique cheeses, zippy toppings, or a fresh side salad. When you take that first bite, with the cheese stretch and spicy chicken, you’ll know: this is comfort food with serious attitude.