Arby’s Horsey Sauce

Jump to Recipe

When you think of Arby’s, the first thing that likely comes to mind is their roast beef sandwich. But let’s be honest, the real star for many is the creamy, zingy Horsey Sauce that comes in those crinkly little packets. That savory heat is the perfect companion to beefy bites, spicy wedges, and just about any meat or hearty dish. Good news: you don’t have to limit yourself to spare sauce packets anymore. You can easily make Arby’s Horsey Sauce at home with a handful of simple ingredients.

This article will walk you through everything you need to recreate the iconic sauce: its taste, texture, common uses, ingredient details, expert tips for getting it just right, and even storage methods. By the end, you’ll be set to make a batch big enough to dip, spread, and drizzle over anything you like.

What Makes Arby’s Horsey Sauce Special?

Horsey Sauce is famous for its unique blend of creamy richness and sharp horseradish kick. It’s not just hot for the sake of heat—each bite delivers a pleasing warmth balanced out by smoothness. The flavor profile lives somewhere between a zesty aioli and a tangy sandwich spread. Unlike ketchup or traditional mustard, Horsey Sauce gives every dish a little extra punch without overpowering it.

This characteristic harmony comes from the combination of mayonnaise and prepared horseradish, lightly sweetened to round off the citrusy tang and earthy spice. Instead of burning the palate, it brightens up meats with every scoop or swipe.

Ingredients: Simple Staples, Big Flavor

Building this sauce doesn’t require any special equipment or hard-to-find components—just a few fridge and pantry staples. Here’s what you’ll need:

• Mayonnaise
  The base. It gives Horsey Sauce its creamy body. Use full-fat mayo for a classic texture. Light or vegan versions also work, but the flavor may shift slightly.

• Prepared Horseradish
  This ingredient supplies the defining heat and aromatic sharpness. Cream-style or regular jarred horseradish both work; the creamier the horseradish, the closer the texture will be to Arby’s version.

• Sugar
  Balances the heat from horseradish and slight tang from mayonnaise. White granulated sugar dissolves easily, but you can use alternatives like honey or agave for subtle variations.

• Salt (optional)
  A small pinch can heighten all the other flavors.

• White Vinegar or Lemon Juice (optional)
  Adds a hint of acidity, brightening the sauce and giving it a more complex profile.

Tip: Keep your ingredients cold to maintain the desired creamy consistency while mixing.

Horsey Sauce Recipe: Step-by-Step Instructions

Ingredients

Notes on Amounts: The exact measure of horseradish and sugar depends on your preferred heat and sweetness. For authentic Arby’s flavor, start with the lower end and adjust after tasting.

Directions

• Combine Base Ingredients
  In a medium mixing bowl, add mayonnaise, horseradish, and sugar.

• Season
  Sprinkle in salt and a splash of vinegar or lemon juice, if using.

• Mix Thoroughly
  Whisk everything until smooth. Make sure there are no streaks or lumps.

• Taste and Adjust
  Sample a small amount. If you prefer more heat, add another spoonful of horseradish. For extra sweetness or tang, stir in a little more sugar or vinegar.

• Chill
  Cover the sauce and refrigerate for at least 30 minutes before serving. This step helps the flavors develop into that classic, unified taste.

• Serve
  Spoon it onto sandwiches, burgers, meats, or use it as a dipping sauce for fries and vegetables.

Customizing Horsey Sauce: Variations and Substitutions

One of the best aspects of making Horsey Sauce at home is that you can tailor it exactly as you like. Here are a few options if you’re feeling adventurous or working with limited ingredients:

• If you want a silkier consistency, add a tablespoon of heavy cream alongside mayo.
• For a lighter version, use Greek yogurt or low-fat mayo as the base.
• Don’t have horseradish? Substitute with a bit of wasabi paste or English mustard for a different but still spicy kick.
• Add chopped fresh chives or a hint of garlic powder for flavor variation.
• Use honey or agave syrup instead of sugar for a touch of floral sweetness.

If you prefer completely smooth sauce, process the mixture in a blender or food processor. If you like some texture, stick to hand mixing.

Tips for Perfect Horsey Sauce Every Time

With just a handful of ingredients, there’s nowhere for mistakes to hide. These tips will ensure top-notch results:

• Choose Fresh Horseradish: The fresher your horseradish, the brighter the flavor. If you grate it yourself, remember it’s much stronger than jarred types—use less and adjust as needed.
• Chill Time: Letting your sauce rest in the fridge for 30 to 60 minutes deepens the flavor and allows the sugar to fully dissolve.
• Storage: Keep finished Horsey Sauce in a tightly sealed jar or container in the refrigerator. It will keep for up to 2 weeks. Don’t freeze it; the mayo will separate and the texture will suffer.
• Small Batches: Horseradish can lose its potency, so make what you’ll use within a week or two for best results.

Pairing Ideas: More Than Roast Beef

Sure, Horsey Sauce shines on an Arby’s-style roast beef sandwich. But you don’t have to stop there. Here are some of my favorite ways to use it:

• Spread on turkey, ham, or prime rib sandwiches
• Added to burgers and sliders for a zesty boost
• As a dip for French fries, potato wedges, or onion rings
• Spooned over grilled steak or chicken to add tangy heat
• Mixed into coleslaw dressing for extra bite
• Blended into deviled egg filling
• As a seafood dip, especially with fried fish or shrimp

You can even swirl a little into mashed potatoes or potato salad for an unexpected zing.

Understanding Horseradish: The Source of Spice

Horseradish is a root vegetable with a pungent profile and assertive heat. When fresh, it’s mild. Once grated or ground, however, natural compounds are exposed to air. This triggers a chemical reaction that brings out horseradish’s signature sharpness.

Prepared horseradish is the most common type used for sauces. It’s typically found near the mustard in grocery stores and comes blended with vinegar to stabilize the flavor.

A few interesting horseradish facts:
– Horseradish has been used for thousands of years in both cooking and traditional medicine.
– The “horse” in horseradish refers to its coarse texture and robust taste.
– It pairs naturally with red meat but also gives a pleasant surprise to vegetarian dishes.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is Horsey Sauce spicy?
It has a notable heat from horseradish, but it’s mellowed by the mayo and sugar. You can control the spiciness by adjusting the horseradish.

2. What can I use if I’m out of horseradish?
Wasabi or English mustard can substitute in a pinch, though the flavor will change.

3. How do I thicken or thin the sauce?
If the sauce is too thick, add a bit of cream or lemon juice. To thicken, simply add more mayo.

4. Can I make it vegan?
Yes, just use vegan mayo.

Arby’s Horsey Sauce is more than just a condiment—it’s a kick of nostalgia and a versatile addition to everything from meat to veggies. When you make it at home, you have full control over the flavor, spiciness, and texture. Pair it with classics like roast beef sandwiches, or branch out into new flavor territory. One bowl, five minutes, and you’ll have a sauce worthy of the Arby’s drive-thru—minus the line.