Papa John’s Garlic Sauce (Easy Copycat)

Jump to Recipe

If you’ve ever found yourself savoring every drop of that creamy, garlicky dip from Papa John’s pizza nights, you’re in good company. Papa John’s Garlic Sauce has earned itself a place as the go-to dipping sauce for pizza lovers everywhere. Forks down, it’s more than just a sidekick for crusts; people slather it over every bite, even sneaking extra little tubs for future meals. Luckily, recreating this iconic sauce at home is easier than you might think, and you only need a few pantry staples.

Let’s dig into exactly how to whip up this easy copycat version. I’ll cover ingredients, variations, serving ideas, and the best ways to store your batch—because trust me, you’ll want to make extra. By the end, you’ll have a creamy, buttery, garlic-laden sauce that rivals the original, and endless ways to put it to work.

What Makes Papa John’s Garlic Sauce So Good?

Papa John’s Garlic Sauce is a simple emulsion, but its magic comes from the balance of fat, salt, and sweet-scented garlic. Unlike many homemade garlic butters, Papa John’s uses margarine as the base, which creates the signature texture and mouthfeel. There’s a unique richness, heightened by a salty hit and rounded out by mellow garlic powder. This isn’t just a dip; it’s an upgrade for almost any savory dish.

Ingredients

The genius of this sauce is in its simplicity. You’ll only need three things for the classic version, but there’s flexibility, so you can tweak the formula to your taste.

• Margarine: This is the key to achieving that smooth, melt-in-your-mouth quality. Papa John’s is loyal to margarine, so for an authentic silkiness, don’t substitute without a plan. Choose a full-fat, plain margarine without extra flavors or additives.
• Garlic powder: Not granules, not fresh—garlic powder delivers that instantaneous, mellow garlic taste. If you love strong garlic flavors, you can experiment with fresh garlic or roasted garlic for a fit that matches your palate.
• Salt: Fine sea salt dissolves best, but regular table salt also works. Salt brings everything together, highlighting both the rich margarine and the mellow heat of the garlic.

Ingredient Alternatives and Additions

If you prefer, you can swap margarine for unsalted butter for a more decadent, farmhouse flavor, or try vegan butter if you want a plant-based version. For a more vibrant color and earthy flavor, blend in a pinch of parsley or even chives.

Optional extras: Add a tiny shake of onion powder, a pinch of chili flakes, or a splash of lemon juice for a tangy twist.

How To Make Papa John’s Garlic Sauce

You’re only a few minutes away from a batch of this golden, garlicky sauce. Here’s a no-fuss process.

Step 1: Melt the Margarine

Place margarine in a small saucepan over low heat. Allow it to melt slowly without bubbling or browning. Heating gently is key—this keeps the sauce creamy rather than greasy.

Step 2: Add Garlic and Salt

When the margarine is completely liquid, whisk in the garlic powder and salt. Stir well to dissolve the seasonings and to keep the mix smooth.

Step 3: Let It Infuse

Once everything is combined, remove from heat. Let the sauce sit for several minutes. This allows the flavors to meld and gives the garlic time to infuse into the margarine.

Step 4: Give It a Whisk

Before serving or storing, whisk again for a perfectly blended, pourable sauce.

Tips and Variations

Everyone’s garlic love-level is different, and this recipe lets you tailor each element to your liking.

• Go heavy on the garlic: Double the garlic powder for a more assertive hit. Or try 1–2 finely minced fresh garlic cloves. For a gentler flavor, use roasted garlic.
• Smooth consistency: Don’t overheat the margarine, or you’ll risk separating the fats. Whisking just before serving will emulsify the sauce.
• Switch up the salt: Try smoked salt or garlic salt for a unique twist.
• Mix-ins: Sprinkle in finely chopped herbs, such as parsley or chives, or a dash of chili flakes for subtle heat.

For the Texture Enthusiast

If you want a supremely silky sauce, opt for clarified butter. Melt butter and skim off the milk solids as they rise, keeping only the golden liquid. This prevents separation and gives you a glossy, restaurant-level finish.

Serving Suggestions

Papa John’s Garlic Sauce is pizza’s faithful companion, but its role can go far beyond the pizza box.

Pair With Pizza

• Homemade pizza: Serve warm for dipping crusts or drizzle over slices for a flavor boost.
• Stuffed crust: Brush garlic sauce inside the dough before baking for extra flavor.

Beyond Pizza

• Garlic bread: Slather over warm bread or rolls and toast under the broiler.
• Chicken: Drizzle over baked or grilled chicken for juicy, garlicky flavor.
• Seafood: Splash onto roast shrimp, salmon, or scallops.
• Vegetables: Toss steamed broccoli, asparagus, or potatoes in the sauce.
• Pasta: Stir into cooked spaghetti with a handful of grated parmesan.
• Mashed potatoes: Swap out some of the butter you’d usually use.
• Steak: Melt a spoonful over hot steak or grilled pork chops.

No matter the main course, garlic sauce amplifies flavors and brings a buttery, savory note that’s hard to resist.

How to Store Garlic Sauce

Once your garlic sauce cools, transfer it to an airtight container. It keeps well in the fridge for up to five days.

Freezing for Later

Garlic sauce freezes beautifully. Pour into ice-cube trays and once solid, store in a freezer bag or container. This way, you can grab just enough for future meals. Frozen portions will keep for up to three months.

Tips for Storing

• Portion control: Smaller cubes mean less waste—thaw only what you need.
• Reheating: Warm gently over low heat, whisking to re-blend if needed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make it vegan?

Absolutely. Most margarine is plant-based, but always check the label for dairy. Use your favorite vegan butter alternative for the same effect.

Will butter work instead of margarine?

Yes. Unsalted butter gives a rich, creamy taste—a little different from the original but equally delicious.

Can I use fresh garlic?

Yes, but use it sparingly; raw garlic is more intense than the powder. For a milder flavor, sauté the minced garlic in margarine before adding salt.

My sauce separated! What do I do?

Let the sauce cool for a few minutes, then whisk briskly to re-emulsify. If it’s too thin, set in the fridge briefly to thicken.

Why Make Papa John’s Garlic Sauce at Home?

Making your own means you control the flavor, the texture, and the ingredients. No artificial fillers, no unknown additives—just pure, buttery garlic joy. You can make it vegan, choose exactly how salty or garlicky you want it, and always have a fresh batch ready.

Quick Reference: Recipe Card

Papa John’s Garlic Sauce (Easy Copycat)

There you have it: the secret to endlessly creamy, garlicky, salty sauce, ready for any mealtime emergency. Papa John’s nailed the formula in their franchises, but once you try this easy copycat at home, you might just skip the pizza order and make it yourself.